Blog

Economics

The AI support billing index: what 11 vendors count and bill

One dated table of what eleven AI support vendors bill for, and what happens to the charge when the customer goes quiet, asks for a person or comes back. Re-read every month.

The short version: as read on each vendor's own pages on 21 October 2026, seven AI support vendors bill per resolution, at $0.49 to $2.00, and their definitions differ far more than their prices. Five of the seven bill a customer who simply goes quiet: Intercom's Fin, Featurebase's Fibi, Help Scout, HubSpot and Gorgias. Zendesk bills silence only when an LLM reading of the transcript confirms the request was resolved, and Salesforce does not say. All seven say a customer who asks for a person is not billed as a resolution, though Gorgias still charges its helpdesk ticket fee. On the customer who comes back, only Fin and Featurebase say a charge already counted is taken off when the customer returns to the same conversation, and HubSpot can bill a second resolution if an email customer replies after 72 hours. Gorgias and Zendesk count nothing until a window of up to 72 hours has closed, and do not say what happens after it. Help Scout and Salesforce do not say at all.

None of the four published comparisons we read on 21 October fills in that last question vendor by vendor, and it is the one that decides whether a per-resolution bill can be checked at all. A resolution that is billed and never reversed when the customer writes back the next day is a charge for something that did not happen. This index puts the rules side by side, one row per vendor, each cell from the vendor's own page with the date it was read, and it will be re-read every month with the changes listed at the bottom.

What each AI support vendor bills, and the price, as of 21 October 2026

Eleven vendors, twelve rows: Salesforce sells its Help Agent per resolution and its other agents by Flex Credits, and also sells Conversations and per-user licences. Most of these prices sit on top of a help desk plan or seats, which the table shows only for Fin. Vendors that sell only on contract, such as Ada, Decagon and Sierra, publish no list price and have no row; more vendors will be added as their pages are checked.

The unit each vendor bills and its listed price. From the vendors' own pages, read 21 October 2026; every row except Zendesk's price rechecked 4 November 2026.
Vendor The billed unit Price, 21 Oct 2026
FibiFeaturebase A resolution, confirmed or assumed, at most one per conversation $0.49
Customer agentHubSpot A resolved conversation, or a lead marked qualified, partially qualified or not qualified 50 HubSpot credits, $0.50 at $10 per 1,000 credits. Voice: 50 credits a minute
ScoutHelp Scout An AI chat session resolved without help from a person, once per session $0.75
FinIntercom An outcome: a resolution, a procedure that ends in a hand-off, or a Fin for Sales result. One per conversation $0.99; a sales qualification $9.99. Fin with another help desk: a $49 a month base plan that includes 50
AI AgentGorgias An automated interaction, charged on top of the helpdesk ticket fee Sold in plan blocks: $1.00 each on monthly billing (190 for $190 on Pro), $0.90 on annual
AI agentsZendesk An automated resolution. Only the "Verified" tier counts against the allowance $1.50 committed, $2.00 pay as you go. Plans include some
Help AgentSalesforce An issue the agent resolves on its own, start to finish Not displayed. A hidden column in the pricing page's code reads "Help Agent Resolutions" at $2
Freddy AI AgentFreshdesk A session: everything within 24 hours of the start of a chat, or 72 hours of the first email $49 per 100 sessions
HugoCrisp Token-based usage credits, drawn until the conversation is resolved, routed or escalated Paid plans include $5 to $75 of credits a month. Crisp estimates $0.05 to $0.10 a conversation
Helply Credits per AI action: 1 for a simple action, 4 for a lookup, 12 for a full investigation Monthly credit blocks from $49
eesel AI One credit per ticket or chat the agent works on, however long Paid plans from $299 a month for 500 credits. Overage $0.80 a credit. Free trial: 100 credits
AgentforceSalesforce, Flex Credits Each action the agent takes. Salesforce's own example prices one action at 20 credits $500 per 100,000 credits, so $0.10 an action in that example

The prices are not comparable as they stand. Seven of the twelve rows are priced per resolution, but a resolution at $0.49 under Featurebase's rules and one at $2.00 under Zendesk's are different events, as the next table shows. Two units are not resolutions at all: HubSpot counts a lead marked "not qualified" as a resolution, and Fin counts a procedure that ends by handing the conversation to your team as an outcome at the same $0.99. We set out how to compare prices sold in different units in our piece on AI support pricing models, and what each of Fin's outcome types is in what counts as an outcome.

Who bills silence, hand-offs and reopens

The seven vendors that bill per resolution, plus Freshdesk, which bills the session. Each cell is what the vendor's own billing page says, read 21 October 2026. "Not stated" means the page does not say.

What happens to the charge in three common cases. From the vendors' own pages, read 21 October 2026 and rechecked 4 November 2026.
Vendor Customer goes quiet Customer asks for a person Customer comes back
FinIntercom Billed, as an assumed resolution, 24 hours after Fin's last answer, per Fin's help centre. Intercom's help article gives no wait Not billed. A procedure you set to end in a hand-off is billed Charge deducted if they return to the same conversation, even in a later billing period
FibiFeaturebase Billed, after 3 minutes of inactivity Not billed. A teammate joining unasked after an answer does not stop the charge Deducted on return to the same conversation; never more than one charge per conversation
ScoutHelp Scout Billed if they ask for no more help after the last AI response. No wait stated Not billed Not stated
Customer agentHubSpot Billed, once 72 hours pass after the customer's last message, if the agent shared a source or took an action Not billed. Assignment by your team or a workflow does not count as a hand-off An email reply after 72 hours reopens it, and a further resolution uses more credits
AI AgentGorgias Billed, if no person is needed within 72 hours No automation fee. The ticket fee still applies Not billed as automated if a person is needed within 72 hours. After that, not stated
AI agentsZendesk Counted only if an LLM check confirms it was resolved, once the conversation ends: 2 hours after the first message on messaging (up to 72 on request), 72 hours after the first email Not counted: an "Assisted escalation" A request for more help before the conversation ends stops the count. After that, not stated
Help AgentSalesforce Not stated, beyond no charge if the customer "walks away unhappy" Not billed, and nor is negative feedback Not stated
Freddy AI AgentFreshdesk No resolution test is described: the session is the unit Not stated Not stated. A new session after 24 hours (chat) or 72 hours (email) is implied by the definition, not said

Zendesk wins the silence column. Its help centre says a conversation where the customer simply stopped is a "Contained resolution", which does not count against the allowance, unless an LLM reading of the transcript confirms the request was resolved. No other vendor in the table describes a check between silence and the invoice. The check is Zendesk's own model grading Zendesk's own agent, which a buyer cannot inspect, but it is a check, and it runs in the buyer's favour.

Fin and Featurebase win the last column. Both say, in nearly the same words, that if the customer later returns to the same conversation for more help, a resolution already counted is deducted, even across billing periods. Featurebase's FAQ adds that a conversation is billed once at most, even if it is reopened. Both rules cover the same conversation only. A customer who starts a new conversation about the same problem is a new conversation on both. We follow that customer across eight vendors in our piece on whether reopened conversations are billed twice.

Salesforce has the broadest exclusion. Its Help Agent announcement of 25 June 2026 says there is no charge if the customer asks for a human, gives negative feedback or "walks away unhappy". The announcement does not say how an unhappy departure is told apart from a satisfied one, and the Agentforce pricing page does not display a Help Agent price, though a hidden column in its code reads $2.

HubSpot and Featurebase can both bill a conversation your team stepped into, unless the customer asked for a person. HubSpot's help centre says only a hand-off the visitor starts stops the charge, and that assignment by your team or a workflow does not by itself prevent a resolution. Featurebase's FAQ says a teammate joining after Fibi has answered, without the customer asking for help, is charged. We set out why that matters in our piece on whether hand-offs are billed; the silent cases are in what is an assumed resolution.

The vendors that bill the work, not the resolution

Four rows in the first table have no resolution test, and so nothing in the second table to argue about. Crisp bills Hugo by token-based usage until the conversation is resolved, routed or escalated, and publishes its own estimate of what a conversation costs. Helply prices each AI action by complexity and says retries, failed actions, drafts your team rejects before they reach a customer, and spam cost nothing. eesel charges one credit per ticket the agent works on, and none for tickets you tell it to leave alone. Salesforce's Flex Credits price each action.

This is fair billing, stated plainly. You pay for work whether or not it resolves anything, and every one of these vendors says so on its own pages. The risk is different, not hidden: an AI that works a conversation and then hands it over has still been paid. What these units do not give you is a resolution count to audit, because they never claimed one.

What changed since we last read these pages

Most of these vendors were last read for this blog between 23 September and 14 October 2026. Three things have moved since.

  • eesel AI replaced per-task pricing with monthly credit blocks. The Internet Archive's capture of its pricing page on 20 September 2026 still showed pay-as-you-go pricing at $0.40 per ticket. By the capture of 3 October 2026 the page showed monthly blocks from $299 for 500 credits, one credit per ticket or chat. Older posts on this blog that gave $0.40 were corrected on 4 November 2026.
  • Help Scout's billing article now calls its AI "Scout". It was "AI Answers" when we read the page on 7 October. The price, $0.75, and the definition are unchanged.
  • Fin's reported Resolution Rate has been recalculated. A Fin help article says conversations where Fin was active but had no opportunity to answer ("Fin Constrained") are now excluded from the denominator, so the Resolution Rate has risen. Existing workspaces moved to the new definition between 1 and 8 July 2026, and figures under it are available back to 1 October 2025. The same article says the number of resolutions and billing are not affected. Our piece on resolution, deflection and containment rates sets out what the change does to the headline rate, and a similar change at Zendesk.

How to read any vendor's billing rule

The vendors above publish their rules; the method works the same for one that sends them on request.

  1. Find the billing page, not the pricing page. The rule usually lives in a help article with "billing", "outcomes" or "resolutions" in its title. A pricing page gives the price of a unit and rarely its definition.
  2. Write down the unit. Resolution, outcome, session, action or ticket. If it is not a resolution, the rest of this list is about what the work costs, not what was resolved.
  3. Find the silence rule. Does a customer who stops replying count as resolved, and after how long? If the page does not give a wait, ask for it in writing.
  4. Find who can stop the charge. The customer asking for a person, the AI escalating, your rules sending it on, or your team stepping in. Vendors treat these four differently.
  5. Find the reopen rule. Is a charge reversed when the customer comes back, in the same conversation and in a new one, and for how long?
  6. Ask for the list of billed conversations. Read forty at random and mark each resolved or not by your own judgement. If the vendor cannot give you the list, you cannot check the bill.

To turn that reading into a figure for your budget, see how to calculate the real cost per resolution.

Where Varley stands

Varley sells a competing AI support agent priced per resolution, so read this section as a vendor talking about itself. It is not in the tables above, because a vendor grading its own rules is not evidence. Everything above this section can be checked on the vendors' own pages.

In Agent mode Varley's price is $0.50 per resolution, the early-access price for direct use on the pricing page as of 28 September 2026. Work Varley does alongside your team, such as drafting a reply, is priced per action on the same page, from $0.001 to $0.10, and is never billed as a resolution. Inside Agent mode, the steps Varley takes to reach a resolution are not billed at all. Its definition, How we count a resolution (version 1.1), answers the three columns this way. A customer who stops replying is not billed: "Silence never counts, however long it runs". A hand-off is not billed: "You are never charged for a conversation Varley hands to a human." And a customer who comes back: "If a customer comes back about the same issue within 30 days, the original charge is credited back in full and the conversation is treated as never resolved." Whether it is the same issue is a judgement, and the page says it is recorded with the reason so you can disagree with it.

Get early access to Varley.

Right of reply

None of the companies named here was approached before publication. Every claim is taken from their own public pages, read on 21 October 2026 and re-read on 4 November 2026, except Zendesk's prices. If anything on this page is wrong or has changed, write to support@dragapp.com and the correction will be published here with a date, including if it is inconvenient for us.

Questions

Which AI support vendors bill for assumed resolutions?

Of the per-resolution vendors in this index, as read on 21 October 2026: Intercom's Fin, Featurebase's Fibi, Help Scout, HubSpot and Gorgias all count a customer who leaves without asking for more help as resolved. The stated waits run from 3 minutes (Featurebase) and 24 hours (Fin) to 72 hours (HubSpot, Gorgias); Help Scout states none. Zendesk counts silence only after an LLM check.

Do AI support vendors refund a resolution if the customer comes back?

Few say. Intercom and Featurebase deduct a charged resolution when the customer returns to the same conversation, even in a later billing period. HubSpot treats an email reply after 72 hours as a reopened conversation that can be billed again. Gorgias and Zendesk count nothing until their window closes; Help Scout and Salesforce do not say. Ask before signing, and ask about new conversations on the same problem.

Why do per-resolution prices differ so much?

Because the vendors are not selling the same thing. A $0.49 resolution that includes a customer who went quiet for three minutes and a $2.00 resolution that has passed a model's check of the transcript are different purchases. Compare the definitions first, then divide your expected monthly bill by the number of conversations you believe were really resolved.

Is paying per session or per credit worse than paying per resolution?

Not necessarily. Session and credit pricing charges for the AI's work whether or not it resolves anything, and the vendors say so openly. Per-resolution pricing puts more of the failure risk on the vendor, but only as far as its definition allows. The cheaper model for you depends on how often the AI really finishes the job.

Changes to this index

4 Nov 2026
Monthly re-read. Every billing rule in both tables, and every price except Zendesk's, re-read on the vendor's own page in a browser on 4 November 2026: none had changed. Zendesk's pricing page redirected to its UK edition in pounds, so its dollar prices stand as read on 21 October. Crisp updated its Hugo billing article on 1 November 2026 with no change to the substance used here. Added the dates of Fin's Resolution Rate change.
21 Oct 2026
First published. Eleven vendors, every page read on 21 October 2026. Next full re-read: 4 November 2026.

Sources